Reviews Brighton Published 10 May 2018

Review: Why I Had to Leave the North at Brighton Fringe 2018

7 - 13 May 2018

Fancy hats and flower arranging: Tracey Sinclair reviews comedian Simon Topping’s solo show.

Tracey Sinclair
Why I had to Leave the North at the Brighton Fringe 2018

Why I had to Leave the North at the Brighton Fringe 2018

Comedian Simon Topping’s first solo show is an engaging if slightly undercooked biographical piece, tracing his life from a childhood in the post-industrial northern town where he grew up, to the south, where he made his home.

Working through a loosely strung together series of anecdotes and slipping through a variety of characters (his hard-working navvy grandfather, his mother, his anarchic brother), Topping presents a life marred by early grief, upheaval and otherness. His father died suddenly when he was young, he discovered a brother he didn’t know he had, and he grew up a boy loving fancy hats and flower arranging in a place with fairly set ideas about masculinity.

Topping’s background is in improv, and it shows – both to the production’s benefit and its detriment. He’s a performer of considerable charm, immensely likeable, and there’s a pleasing freewheeling spontaneity to the piece, peppered with plenty of laughs. We are treated to a slideshow of family photos, birthday cards and sibling Facebook chats, interspersed with the easy nostalgia of communal cultural touchstones (The A-Team, Big Daddy and Giant Haystacks).

But even with its hour-long running time, the piece could be much tighter – some bits work better than others, and although it feels commendably honest, it lacks genuine depth. There’s a feeling of skating the surface that it never quite shakes, a skittering away from any real examination of the issues it covers.

(In fairness, this is not helped the production is fighting against an ill-suited venue, with raucous conversations from the curtained-off café next door regularly spilling into show. While this did give it an intimate air – like leaning into a friend’s conversation in a rowdy pub – there were also moments when my attention was pulled from what was happening to Topping’s family to the loudly recounted drama of Susan’s hen-night.)

There’s the bones of a fascinating piece here – an examination of toxic masculinity (embodied by Topping’s ex-soldier brother and his penchant for inappropriate nudity), grief and the roles in life we assign ourselves, and how we fight those assigned to us by others – but to find them, it needs to dig much deeper. But it’s a promising first show, with enough raw material to feel that, with a little bit of polish, it could truly shine.

Why I Had to Leave the North is on until 13 May 2018 at the Brighton Fringe. Click here for more details. 


Tracey Sinclair

Tracey Sinclair is a freelance editor and writer, a published author and performed playwright. She writes for a number of print and online magazines and most recently has focused on the Dark Dates series of books, including A Vampire in Edinburgh. You can follow her on Twitter under the profoundly misleading name @thriftygal

Review: Why I Had to Leave the North at Brighton Fringe 2018 Show Info

Directed by Simon Topping

Written by Simon Topping (Co-Editor Thea Anderson)

Cast includes Simon Topping


Most Popular Articles

in the past seven days


Enter your email address below to get an occasional email with Exeunt updates and featured articles.