Reviews NationalNewcastle Published 31 October 2019

Review: Alex and Eliza at Northern Stage

29th October, then touring

Life story: Tracey Sinclair writes on Umar Butt’s charming, personal show about his grandmother’s life, set during the Partition of India.

Tracey Sinclair
Seweryna Dudzińska and Umar Butt in Alex and Eliza at Northern Stage. Design, Hannah Sibai; lighting design, Nick Hare.

Seweryna Dudzińska and Umar Butt in Alex and Eliza at Northern Stage. Design, Hannah Sibai; lighting design, Nick Hare.

Writer/director Umar Butt’s Alex & Eliza is a very personal tale of family, based on the life of his grandparents. By turns funny, charming and moving, it deftly balances humour with an often tragic story that spans the personal and political.

Butt, who also stars, is a young Glaswegian Muslim, generally content with life, though chafing against the constraints of his religious family and wanting to pursue a career in the arts. When his home-loving, devout grandmother comes to stay when his parents are out of town (the first time, to his knowledge, she has left her village in rural Pakistan), he’s astonished to find she is an accomplished musician – and more shocked still when she reveals the details of a remarkable life played out against the backdrop of political upheaval and personal tragedy.

It’s a powerful story, simply but beautifully told. While not shying away from the horrors of his grandmother’s history – which include losing her home and her father during the Partition, and having to reinvent herself to hide her white Christian heritage – Butt handles it with an admirable lightness of touch that includes some witty lines, crowd-pleasing pop culture references and well-placed fourth wall breaking.

A strong cast handles multiple roles well (some questionable accents aside). Seweryna DudziÅ„ska brings a vividness to the young Eliza that matures to the almost ethereal serenity of an old woman who has seen too much but found joy in the simple but significant pleasures of family life, while Danny Charles is sympathetic both as her father, and as Butt’s hard-drinking but amiable friend, whose easy-going banter hides secrets of his own.

The piece makes smart use of Hannah Sibai’s sparse but versatile set, and the evocative music is well-deployed (props both to Musical Director Ross Clark and on-stage musician Laura Stutter.) Although the pacing could be tighter and some of the lighter scenes feel a little random, this is a production to be applauded. It skilfully tackles an area of colonial history that too many Brits are still shamefully ignorant about without ever being too heavy-handed – my own knowledge of Partition has been mainly formed by a few Merchant Ivory films and that episode of Doctor Who: yay for the English education system! – while at the same time exploring those most universal of themes: family, home, and love.

Alex and Eliza was at Northern Stage on 29th October. It tours to Traverse Theatre, Edinburgh in November. More info here.


Tracey Sinclair

Tracey Sinclair is a freelance editor and writer, a published author and performed playwright. She writes for a number of print and online magazines and most recently has focused on the Dark Dates series of books, including A Vampire in Edinburgh. You can follow her on Twitter under the profoundly misleading name @thriftygal

Review: Alex and Eliza at Northern Stage Show Info

Directed by Umar Butt

Written by Umar Butt

Cast includes Umar Butt, Danny Charles, Seweryna Dudzińska, Laura Stutter



Enter your email address below to get an occasional email with Exeunt updates and featured articles.