Reviews Edinburgh Published 21 August 2015

The Paradise Project

Summerhall ⋄ 8th - 30th August 2015

Building a better world.

Catherine Love

Jerry Killick and Stacey Sampson are starting over. Fed up with the world as it is, they’re trying again, making new rules and fixing what’s wrong. Alone together on stage, they construct this new world around them, assembling the walls and slotting together tables and chairs. Except moral principles and decision-making processes are a little trickier than flat-pack furniture.

As the title suggests, Third Angel’s new show is about building paradise – or at least trying to. In a scenario unsettlingly free of context, two people (the performers vary from show to show) are in search of utopia. In little vignettes, they talk in circles, playing games with language and ideas. They debate what should and shouldn’t be allowed, what’s right and what’s wrong, how to distribute resources equitably. In between these discussions, they take it in turn to read from a series of files, each outlining previous attempts to establish a better world. All of them have failed.

The trouble is, decisions are always specific rather than abstract. As Sampson argues, almost everything – from killing to theft – is justifiable under certain circumstances. How can you create the framework for a new, better society without knowing all the particulars? It’s all very well writing rules in theory, but in practice rules are inevitably bent. What happens when one person’s need is greater than another? And who has the final say when disagreements are insurmountable?

As a set of knotty philosophical discussions, The Paradise Project is fascinating. These are questions that we as a society need to be constantly grappling with, accepting that we might never reach an answer yet insistently asking nonetheless. But it all feels a little distant, the ideas as cool and clinical as José Capela’s pristine white set. There are smatterings of humour, but precious little other emotion. And without reaching into the heart, how can we ever hope to discover paradise?


Catherine Love

Catherine is a freelance arts journalist and theatre critic. She writes regularly for titles including The Guardian, The Stage and WhatsOnStage. She is also currently an AHRC funded PhD candidate at Royal Holloway, University of London, pursuing research into the relationship between text and performance in 21st century British theatre.

The Paradise Project Show Info

Produced by Third Angel

Cast includes Jerry Killick, Stacey Sampson, Chris Thorpe, Rachael Walton, Tânia Alves, Jorge Andrade


Most Popular Articles

in the past seven days


Enter your email address below to get an occasional email with Exeunt updates and featured articles.